Comments on: Isa bin Maryam (Jesus son of Mary) and Learned and Eminent Scholars of Islam http://rationality.ca/2008/06/18/isa-bin-maryam-jesus-son-of-mary-and-learned-and-eminent-scholars-of-islam/ based on or in accordance with reason or logic Mon, 30 Jan 2012 23:06:44 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: saadb http://rationality.ca/2008/06/18/isa-bin-maryam-jesus-son-of-mary-and-learned-and-eminent-scholars-of-islam/comment-page-1/#comment-314 saadb Sun, 22 Jun 2008 16:18:54 +0000 http://rationality.ca/?p=31#comment-314 Jazak'Allah Jazak’Allah

]]> By: admin http://rationality.ca/2008/06/18/isa-bin-maryam-jesus-son-of-mary-and-learned-and-eminent-scholars-of-islam/comment-page-1/#comment-311 admin Sun, 22 Jun 2008 01:42:58 +0000 http://rationality.ca/?p=31#comment-311 Basically he has bracketed both Hadhrat Isa (Jesus) and Hadhrat Musa (Moses) - may peace of Allah be upon them - in his writing and used the same word <i>twafi</i> (death) for both of them... which can only mean death because no one believes that Hadhrat Musa (alaihi salam) did not die. Basically he has bracketed both Hadhrat Isa (Jesus) and Hadhrat Musa (Moses) – may peace of Allah be upon them – in his writing and used the same word twafi (death) for both of them… which can only mean death because no one believes that Hadhrat Musa (alaihi salam) did not die.

]]> By: saadb http://rationality.ca/2008/06/18/isa-bin-maryam-jesus-son-of-mary-and-learned-and-eminent-scholars-of-islam/comment-page-1/#comment-310 saadb Sat, 21 Jun 2008 23:56:17 +0000 http://rationality.ca/?p=31#comment-310 Jazak'Allah, for that brother this should help me when debating with a brother i know as he ranks Ibne Tamiyyah(rh) highly. Also brother if it not to much hassle could you write a breif summmary of what it says as i do not understand Arabic (sorry for the trouble). Jazak’Allah, for that brother this should help me when debating with a brother i know as he ranks Ibne Tamiyyah(rh) highly.

Also brother if it not to much hassle could you write a breif summmary of what it says as i do not understand Arabic (sorry for the trouble).

]]> By: admin http://rationality.ca/2008/06/18/isa-bin-maryam-jesus-son-of-mary-and-learned-and-eminent-scholars-of-islam/comment-page-1/#comment-309 admin Sat, 21 Jun 2008 20:20:22 +0000 http://rationality.ca/?p=31#comment-309 wa alaikum assalam wr wb, Yes, that is correct. Here is the scanned copy: http://rationality.ca/d/Taymiyyah.pdf Reference and book name etc.: <p align=right dir=rtl> الجزء الاول من مجموعہ الرساءل الکبری ۔ تالیف شیخ الاسلام تقی الدین ابی العباس احمد بن عبدالحلیم ابن عبدالسلام بن تیمیہ الحرانی الدمشقی المتوفی سنہ ۷۲۸ھ، ص ۸۰، ۸۱، الطبعہ الاولی سنہ ۱۳۲۳ھ بالمطبعہ العامرۃ الشرفیۃ بمصر </p> All errors in transcribing names/references are mine :) they are from my notes that I prepared over 10+ years ago. wa alaikum assalam wr wb,

Yes, that is correct. Here is the scanned copy: http://rationality.ca/d/Taymiyyah.pdf

Reference and book name etc.:

الجزء الاول من مجموعہ الرساءل الکبری ۔ تالیف شیخ الاسلام تقی الدین ابی العباس احمد بن عبدالحلیم ابن عبدالسلام بن تیمیہ الحرانی الدمشقی المتوفی سنہ ۷۲۸ھ، ص ۸۰، ۸۱، الطبعہ الاولی سنہ ۱۳۲۳ھ بالمطبعہ العامرۃ الشرفیۃ بمصر

All errors in transcribing names/references are mine :) they are from my notes that I prepared over 10+ years ago.

]]> By: saadb http://rationality.ca/2008/06/18/isa-bin-maryam-jesus-son-of-mary-and-learned-and-eminent-scholars-of-islam/comment-page-1/#comment-308 saadb Sat, 21 Jun 2008 11:49:52 +0000 http://rationality.ca/?p=31#comment-308 Asalamulaikum, Brother when you say Allama Ibn-e-Timia are you talking about Taqi ad-Din Ahmad ibn Taymiyyah ??? If so could you please give me referce to the page or kindly somehow upload it onto your site please. Asalamulaikum,

Brother when you say Allama Ibn-e-Timia are you talking about Taqi ad-Din Ahmad ibn Taymiyyah ??? If so could you please give me referce to the page or kindly somehow upload it onto your site please.

]]>